Tan discusses the different ways in which she uses English. Or maybe it was inability to complete a sentence or two? Her use of inductive reasoning proves her point that different people use different forms of language. At the beginning of the piece we are told about the different types of english she would speak with her mother and with everyone else; we are then told how english wasn't Amy's strongest subject and later on we are told about the difficulties her mother experienced because of the way she spoke english and the prejudice she faced. Actually, language has encouraged my growth in life through offering different ideas and ways of handling life issues. Anne Lamott discusses how you should not be afraid to write your first draft of a paper, it is suppose to be horrible. For starters, Amy Tan finds herself in a struggle with her linguistic identity. Tan fills the first half of her essay with examples and illustrations of when she needed to talk for her mother because the people who they were dealing with were being rude, unhelpful and not giving them good service.
As a mother tongue, these people have the allowance for an advantage unlike them that have to learn. However, some of Tan's friends confessed that her mother language was not very comprehensive because most of them could only get 50% or less what Tan's mother was trying to say. Amy defends her mother's 'Broken' English by the fact that she is Chinese and that the 'Simple' English spoken in her family 'Has become a language of intimacy, a different sort of English that relates to family talk' 36. At times people make mistakes when pronouncing certain words, this does not make them less intelligent or lack proper education. Recently, I was made keenly aware of the different Englishes I do use.
In one of her many talks about her book, The Joy Luck Club, Amy Tan display such a great mastery of language, the kind of language she had learned from school and her extensive reading, with carefully articulated grammar, in the audience of her mother who was in her company. Bringing this awareness makes us more aware how we communicate, and how we react while others are communicating with us. After she shows the way that her mother talks, she tells us two stories about her mother that she received unfair treatment in bank and hospital because of her language. Also, she lets her readers to compare her stories to their own and make them to think thoroughly about their own languages. It is not only a tool of communication but a sociological tool of measuring individual worth.
This might suggest that the use of language through writing is the way she expresses herself or gets her point across. Most immigrant students lived with challenges based on language difficulties as well as literacy and culture. Select 4-5 words you think are most important in the text. Both had parents whose grasp of the English language was quite weak. I think that the main purpose of this article is to show people that there is no right type of english, and that english comes in many forms therefore there should be no prejudice. The main ideas that the author appears to communicate in this article are that the notion of a perfect language is not entirely the driving force behind what it is and what is not of other versions of the English language spoken. Her mum is seen to face a lot of challenges and prejudice from the people around her.
Tan keenly observed the different types of English in several instances like when giving a talk about her book and her mother was part of her audience; she realizes that she been using academic language from the book which is different from the language they used at home. She appears to have contemplated extensively on the power and role of language and expresses her perspective through this essay. Bilingualism and Its Impact on Parent-Child Relationships Noted authors, Amy Tan and Richard Rodriguez, authors of Mother Tongue and Public and Private Language respectively, have something in common which most people may not realize at first. The doctor ignored her mother because he could not understand her English. Providing the subjective point of view, it is clear that Amy feels very strong and passionate with the connection to her mother. She does not end her essay by listing her personal experiences. In fact, she does not bend so much into displaying her mastery of the literary devices when she envisions her mum as her intended audience in the stories she wrote about mothers and daughters whose intended audience is mainly women.
The combination of which would cause any normal child's head to explode as it tried to sort out the mess of an English language that swarmed inside her brain. This is a very common misconception by people; don? Moreover throughout the text has a pattern of using a personal experience then expanding on it. The use of English however must be put in context just like Amy Tan narrated when she. Her mother speaks a little bit differently than most Americans but she can get her point across to her daughter, who is an English major, as clear as day. Both overcame the odds in learning English in order to become successful in their chosen careers Possible Thesis Statements 1. The essay is straight and to the point. It is assumed that migrants are uneducated; this is not true because Amy points out that Asian students excel in math and science as compared to English.
Tan was discriminated even by her neurologist who is supposed to be listening keenly to patient despite the language barrier. She sets up the essay with a specific intention in mind. She even thinks that her family language could have limited her from accessing several opportunities. . Gene is the character who has to deal with all these things in his life, because of his relations with Finny and Leper.
People around her treated her less serious, some would even ignore her with sharp brutality, seeing her in the light of someone with some kind disability or some sort of incompleteness. English enabled her to gain knowledge, recognize the world around her; hence, she considered it her mother tongue. She thought it was the reason for all her not-doing-so-well in Verbal skill and also responsible for her ill performance in achievement tests. We live in a globalized world where different cultures are in constant interaction. She proved how her mother encountered a different kind of attitude when she tried to communicate with other people.
Tan talks about how she was praying for the blonde haired boy and a slim new American nose. Amy tried and succeeded, we may try to adapt on our side, but that does not call for shunning when the going gets tough. The fact that these… 1290 Words 6 Pages understood and what is not. And by that definition, I am someone who has always loved language. The article discusses the different languages of English that Tan had learned and frequently used throughout her life. Language determines the culture one has to adapt and incorporate.
Her life was widely dependant of her knowledge in different languages that constituted of English. As a child, English was an unexplained aspect of unfairness. Today, many young people like me have to forego our mother tongue languages for foreign ones like English. Instead, she listened and practiced quietly until she was sure of herself. Language is the tool of my trade. Then, she suggests reasons of the change in her own speaking. In fact, her success in the latter, depicted by her writing capabilities, was a source of surprise both to her family and to friends.