The essay compares the different experiences immigrants go through when leaving their native countries. Bharati traveled around North America with her husband being an American citizen. I also feel like life is going to be tougher for Mira because she did not choose to adapt to the American culture, but she chose to stay with her Indian culture. Mira deals with America but still treasures India more. It was written to address a movement in Congress to take away government benefits from resident aliens. Two Ways To Belong In America Essays 1 - 30 Anti Essays Get access to Two Ways To Belong In America Essays. Parallelism of phrasings not only exemplifies her level of literacy but also strongly emphasizes her argument and strikes the readers.
One is not normally offered the option of being an insider, let alone on one's own terms. Compare and Contrast: The entire essay also consists of compare and contrast. She means that she doesn't have to do all the things that would otherwise be expected of her if she would have married an Indian guy like wearing certain types of clothes or eating certain types of food. Two ways to mke it to America. I was prepared for and even welcomed the emotional strain that came with marrying outside my ethnic community. They hardly ever see each other.
She is happier to live in America as expatriate Indian than as an immigrant American. I am moved that thousands of long-term residents are finally taking the oath of citizenship. The facts and emotions stated by Mukherjee's first hand experience holds great power which reinforces her whole purpose in writing such piece of art. Everyone in my family went straight into the workforce or military after high school. I think it is neat that this reading pertains to diversity and ethnicity because it ties in with a business lecture I just had today.
The Mukherjee sisters find themselves on different sides in the current debate over the status of immigrants. I could portray a comparison between me and my brother because we are in the same situation as she was. I like how you took on a different approach and related the essay to your own friends. You personalized your response just enough to make a connection, but not too much that it became about you. The fact that your friends have been encouraged to get married and find a good guy to take care of them is far different with what you have been encouraged to do from your parents. To this extent, I should like to offer some biography on Ernest Hemingway which may serve to illuminate this belief.
Two ways to belong in america essay - Pros of Using Paper. Their original plan was to endure two years in America, secure their degrees, then return to India to marry the grooms of their fathers choosing. I am not sure what I would do if I moved to a different country. To belong in America is not only to be a legal inhabitant of the U. How can you belong in.
Mira wants to be just a visitor to America and Bharati wants to feel like she belongs here. Her older sister moved to the United States in 1960 to study psychology and pre-school education. Her parents kind of put education to the side. Both sisters moved to United States in hope to pursue their dreams and to achieve they goals with college and further education. It is interesting to see how the two sisters differed.
Mukherjee and her sister only intended to stay in America for two years. Yet, her sister has taken on change with open arms, and has entered a new speech community on her own. Tomorrow when you wake up from that dream everything will be back on own place like it suppose to be. They only have a relationship over the phone. Bharati is an American citizen, and married outside of her culture.
Mira ended up marrying an Indian student and keeping her Indian citizenship and status as a legal immigrant because she wanted to stay true to her culture. I could only imagine being Mira and only talking to indians day in and day out. I liked how you could relate to some extent to how the girls were feeling in this article, it helped me understand better the reasons behind why the girls chose the path they chose. They soon acquired the labor certifications necessary for the green card of hassle-free residence and employment. This is the case in a story between these two sisters that came from Calcutta, India.
I also find it interesting that Mira decided to hold onto her heritage and what not. The thesis of this book is to show how the two sisters who migrated to America reacted differently to the environment. Two Ways to Belong in America Bharati Mukherjee - Foreign. The conditions in third world countries have become so terrible that it's come to the point where it's not surprising anymore why so many people immigrate to this country every year! If a person is living illegally in America, then they don't belong in here. As Mira who married an Indian boy she stuck to the culture and morals of her family. I was only 19 years old moving from my home country to United States. Speaking the same as the rest of the community is only one of the differences that set you apart from others.