Oram only spoke to the surviving members after killing off the other fifteen. This is used to justify not pushing a large man on the tracks to stop the incoming train. It can… 1677 Words 7 Pages Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen of the jury. He has a deep conversation with Brigadier Hatfield, discussing the idea of what is wrong and what is not wrong about executing a fellow soldier. Human life so ending it without knowledge of just cause seems unfair to many.
In the interests of justice, no trial court should let stand a verdict of guilty where the evidence does not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. I don't think that Lieutenant-Commander Oram made the right decision. It's a hard decision to make, but in my opinon the right decision was made. Hook: The world of morality does non always ladder in shades of black and white, more often than not it ventures into realms of different hues of gray. He took into account where people were in their lives, rather than their status in his crew. Philosophy cannot be easily defined.
It allows us to feel the emotions of the Lieutenant, and understand why he chose between life and death for so many others. The impeached official is also prohibited from serving in public office in the future, although a few people have managed to get around this provision. She was forty years old had no husband or children. Did the Captain make a good decision? As he walked closer the image started to blur and consciousness took precedenc. The captain is facing alot of mental turmoil because of a past decision that took his manhood and courage. As a man of his rank, he seized control and made a decision as such his rank would suggest.
Those who answered are seized by their straight-jacketed minions and subdued while they surgically remove the victim's heart while still alive. The situation gets seemingly worse as the story goes on until finally a gruesome resolution is found. His actions following the incident demonstrate that he is a great commanding officer who at the same time exhibits humane traits. We feel a certain way to moral decisions and we often do not even think as to why. It is relatively easy to save crew member, but difficult to replace a captain.
Other studies are clear on what they stand for. Even though the deaths of the other crew members is very tragic, it is all about basic math. Once his crew reported that the situation was beyond their control, he then ordered the radioman to call the shore station. This demonstrates his awareness of when to seek for external help. Although harsh, I have to agree with the captain's decision. Because Captain Preston was the officer in charge that day, he was accused of murder.
As I come here today, I will explain to you the current state of the United States macro economy. Oram is faced with the dilemma of essentially murdering fifteen men to save five, or allowing everyone to die. How does the author create a sense of urgency in his writing? The propellers were torn off, steering gear ruined, stern tanks flooded, and all the hatches were desperately Jammed. Though the author tries to make it seem as if t. Once we see the events in the submarine, we are taken back to the present to view the court hearing. The plaintiff just told you one side, the side they want you to hear. Not sure what the questioner is asking.
The Writes of these two short stories The Necklace. Furthermore, they could make a prima facie case against any husband when his wife goes missing. In the story, captain Oram kills off fifteen members of crew, by secretly poisoning their drinks to save himself and four other crewmen. Oodgeroo Noonuccal sets her short story in rural Australia at Easter time. But you need to hear both sides before you can know what really happened that evening. This is because the narrating voice enters the minds of most characters, excluding the radio telephone scenes. B What effect does this sequence have on the reader? He is put in a situation where he needs to kill 15 people of his crew to ensure the survival of at least 5.
And I feel bad for the crew members that survived and have to live with the memories of what happened that day. In the United States and many other western countries, you cannot do it again. It depends on the country, in England and Wales, the judge can instruct the jury that a majority verdict is acceptable if the jury can't reach a unanimous verdict. While both Always a Motive and Gentlemen, Your Verdict are written in third person and pull at the readers emotions, Always a Motives theme is how people tend to see things only from one perspective and things can change in an instant while Gentlemen, Your Verdicts theme focuses on the justification of murder in certain circumstances. Captain Phillips had a very difficult relationship with his father. The same respect and diplomacy that is expected of you in the classroom extends to blogging space. So go check them out, i think there are still a few tickets left but you'd better hurry.